Performance Reviews: Expert Advice on Preparation, Feedback, and Career Advancement
By SME Membership
Performance reviews are an integral part of career development but navigating them successfully requires more than just waiting for your manager’s feedback. In SME Membership’s recent SME Career Café, Arthur Hughes, Executive Client Parter and Career Transition & Job Search Strategist, and Jacqueline Connolly-Peros, Certified Master Personal Brand Strategist, shared their expert advice on how employees can turn their performance reviews into valuable career growth opportunities.
Understanding the Performance Review Process
A performance review is typically a formal process where employees receive feedback on their work throughout the year. While organizations may vary in approach, the process generally involves assessing how well an employee has performed against established goals and identifying areas for improvement. Performance reviews should not be viewed as a one-time event, but as part of an ongoing dialogue. If you find yourself unsure of where you stand, solicit feedback ahead of time. This proactive approach can help you prepare for the review and adjust before it’s too late.
The feedback provided during a performance review is designed to help you grow professionally, regardless of whether it’s positive or constructive. It is important to view this as an opportunity to discuss your career development, long-term goals, and necessary steps to continue advancing within the company.
Preparing for Your Performance Review
Preparation is crucial for excelling in a performance review. Tracking and quantifying your achievements throughout the year, including smaller successes. Examples such as meeting deadlines, contributing to key projects, or demonstrating leadership provide concrete evidence to discuss during your review.
Seek feedback from peers, supervisors, and stakeholders beforehand to gain diverse perspectives and a clearer picture of your impact. This approach helps you present a well-rounded view of your contributions and their significance to the organization.
Also, aligning your accomplishments with company goals to highlight how your work drives team and organizational success. While doing this it’s important to showcase your unique strengths – qualities that distinguish you from others in your role.
Navigating Constructive Feedback
Constructive feedback is an inevitable part of most performance reviews, but it doesn’t have to be intimidating. Approach feedback with an open mind, treating it as an opportunity to grow. Feedback is a gift, not an attack. If the feedback is unclear, ask questions to gain clarity and ensure you understand what is being communicated. Active engagement helps you address any potential gaps in your performance and provide valuable guidance on areas for improvement.
That being said, if you disagree with feedback, it is important to advocate for yourself professionally. While it’s essential to maintain respect and openness, asking for more specific examples or clarification can ensure that you receive actionable advice that supports your development.
Managing Cross-Functional Feedback and Team Contributions
In organizations with cross-functional teams or matrix structures, your performance is likely assessed by various stakeholders across departments. It’s important to demonstrate an understanding of how your contributions benefit not just your immediate team, but the wider organization. By framing your work in terms of its broader impact, you show that you can connect the dots between your role and the company’s objectives.
Articulating your performance through specific examples that illustrate your contributions, both qualitative and quantitative. By adapting the STAR method, typically used in interviews, to your performance review, you can leverage a storytelling approach and create a more compelling narrative about your value.
Negotiating Raises and Promotions
After a performance review, many employees seek raises or promotions. While the timing and approach will vary depending on the company and individual circumstances, be prepared to have a clear, evidence-backed case for why they deserve a raise or promotion. A key tip is to be proactive throughout the year – by seeking feedback and learning opportunities – can make a significant difference. Proactive employees are more likely to be considered for stretch assignments and high-visibility projects; regularly demonstrating value can lead to greater career advancement.
Conclusion
A well-executed performance review is an opportunity for growth, not just an evaluation of past performance. By preparing thoroughly, soliciting feedback throughout the year, and confidently discussing your contributions and strengths, you can turn this process into a springboard for your career advancement. Whether you’re seeking constructive feedback or aiming for a promotion, embracing your performance review as a tool for development is key to long-term success.
Ready to take your job search journey to the next level? Join us for the SME Career Cafe, where we dive deeper into topics like navigating the job search. The SME Career Café is your go-to virtual coffee chat series for career-driven individuals. Unlike typical coffee chats, these offer tailored insights, expert advice, and real-world experiences for SME students, emerging professionals, and seasoned professionals. Join us to build a vibrant community, access career resources like the SME Career Center, and network for your career success!
Register for the Next SMECC